Roberta Scipioni Ball’s Tribute to the Italian Spirit

Wendy reviews books set in Italy. For more articles like this one, subscribe to her Substack channel Italy Writers and get in touch via Sunflower Publishing. As an Amazon Associate, we may earn from qualifying purchases. Privacy policy.

In The Peasants of Abruzzo, Roberta Scipioni Ball weaves a sweeping, lyrical tale of migration, hardship, and human resilience. Set against the rugged backdrop of early twentieth-century southern Italy and the uncertain promise of a new life in America, this novel offers both historical depth and emotional intimacy. Though the characters are fictional, the story pulses with the weight of lived experience, drawing inspiration from the author’s ancestral past.

We begin in 1910 in the harsh mountain landscape of Abruzzo, where Anselmo Scipioni, a struggling farmer, sees only two options: risk starvation or leave. Fifty years after Italy’s unification, poverty still grips the southern regions, and Abruzzo remains starkly isolated, its people speaking a dialect barely comprehensible outside their own valleys. Ball captures the weight of generational hardship in sparse, unsentimental prose:

“At the age of 27, Anselmo still lived with his parents and brother, Vittorio. For peasant farmers, (i contadini) it was a means of survival.”

Anselmo is joined in reluctant matrimony by Angela Tortora, a young woman from a nearby village with a twisted spine and a fierce, domineering mother. Angela’s first love—the naive and unknowing Vittorio—slips through her grasp when a plan to entrap him fails. Instead, she marries Anselmo, a man she does not love, and their lives take root not in Italy, but across the sea in upstate New York.

What makes this novel so emotionally resonant is its refusal to romanticise hardship. The emigration itself is described with meticulous care: the days-long journey in a wooden cart to Naples, the two harrowing weeks at sea, the interrogations and medical inspections at Ellis Island. There is no melodrama, only the slow, painful reality of uprooting oneself in the hope of survival.

“Angela could procure flour already milled to a fine powder and olive oil already pressed, in a dark glass bottle. At the greengrocer’s she could buy vegetables she had never seen before with money. How strange to purchase her staples with currency!”

In these quiet observations, Ball captures the profound cultural dislocation faced by immigrants—especially women like Angela, who struggle not only with language and place, but with identity. Angela cannot let go of the old world and refuses to embrace the new. Unlike Anselmo, who finds work as an upholsterer and tries to build a future, Angela is consumed by grief, unable to learn English or navigate the alien customs of American life.

Her inner world is painted with care and sorrow. Angela is not always likeable, but she is real. Her pain is tangible, her stubbornness understandable. The reader feels the weight of her isolation, her longing to be among her own people, speaking a language she understands, performing rituals she knows.

After ten years, when tragedy befalls the family, she returns to Abruzzo—but the Italy she finds is no longer the place she left behind. Mussolini is in power, the political atmosphere is stifling, and survival, once again, becomes a daily struggle. The return is not a homecoming, but a reckoning.

Ball uses this return to underscore a central theme of the novel: exile is not just a physical separation, but a psychological state. Neither Italy nor America offers complete solace, and Angela and Anselmo, for all their sacrifice, never truly belong to either land. Their marriage, too, is shaped by this in-betweenness—not born of love, but of necessity, and yet enduring in its own quiet way.

The backdrop of historical change is deftly handled. From the decline of the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies to the realities of fascism, the novel navigates major political shifts without sacrificing its focus on the domestic and personal. We learn how rural Italian communities lived, how they loved, mourned, worked, and endured.

Descriptions of place are beautifully rendered. The mountains of Abruzzo are wild and untamed, a fitting metaphor for the characters who inhabit them. The contrast with the mechanised, alien world of upstate New York could not be sharper. Yet even there, the beauty of old rituals remains:

“Angela still rose early, kneading bread the way her grandmother had taught her, letting it rise beneath a tea towel while the city hummed quietly outside.”

This attention to domestic detail is one of the novel’s many strengths. It is through these small rituals—cooking, weaving, tending to the sick—that identity and dignity are preserved.

Why I Recommend This Book

The Peasants of Abruzzo is a deeply evocative exploration of the immigrant experience—one that acknowledges the heartbreak, confusion, and ambivalence that accompany great change. It is also an intimate portrait of a region often overlooked in Italian histories. Abruzzo, with its distinct customs, dialects, and landscape, emerges as a character in its own right. Through historical insight and emotional truth, Ball gives voice to the generations who left it behind—and those who remained.

This is not just a novel about immigration, but about cultural memory. About the way land and language shape us, and what is lost when we are forced to let them go. It is also about resilience—not the glossy kind found in motivational posters, but the real, lived endurance of people who kept going in the face of grief, hunger, and uncertainty.

Ball’s prose is spare but lyrical, her pacing unhurried, her characters flawed but unforgettable. The book never shouts; it listens. It honours the silences, the things left unsaid, the strength in small gestures.

Ultimately, this is a novel of legacy—of the traits passed down not only through blood but through story, work, and sacrifice. For readers interested in migration narratives, Italian history, or quietly devastating domestic fiction, this is a story that will linger long after the final page.

With tenderness and grit, The Peasants of Abruzzo reminds us that the past does not only reside in dusty records or fading photographs. It lives in language, in resilience, in the soft determination of those who endured so that others might thrive.

This article was adapted from my original review published on Sunflower Publishing.

Want to see another book review? Read here