The Best Italian Plates in New York

We love unearthing creative experiences about Italy. It’s highly likely this article contains links to products or services that we believe in from one of our affiliate partners – Tripadvisor. Mission accomplished if we’re paid for any link you click on. Read more.

New York City’s Italian dining scene is as dynamic as the city itself. From traditional Neapolitan pizzerias to modern interpretations of Italian classics. These establishments have garnered acclaim not just for their culinary excellence but also for their strong online presence and customer satisfaction. Here are ten must-visit Italian establishments that capture the essence of Italy in the heart of NYC.

Una Pizza Napoletana

Often described as a shrine to pizza, Una Pizza Napoletana is where simplicity becomes sacred. Owned and operated by Anthony Mangieri. This Lower East Side spot has built an almost cult-like following, thanks to its singular focus on traditional Neapolitan pizza done impeccably well. No distractions. No gimmicks. Just pure, wood-fired perfection, handcrafted by Mangieri himself.

Highlights:

• A stripped-down menu featuring classics like Margherita, Marinara, and Bianca
  
• Naturally leavened dough, slow-fermented and blistered just right
  
• One of the few places where the pizzaiolo still makes every single pizza himself
  

Una Pizza Napoletana holds a Google Reviews rating of 4.3 stars from over 750 reviews. Diners praise the crust’s incredible texture and the clarity of flavour in each bite. On TripAdvisor, the score sits around 3.9, with international travellers often commenting on the purity and authenticity of the experience. It’s less about variety, more about mastery.

Over on Instagram, @unapizzanapoletana is followed by a devoted community of more than 120K pizza purists. The feed is a rolling showcase of lightly charred crusts and glistening tomato sauce. The unmistakable aesthetic of a pizzeria that refuses to compromise.

Named the #1 pizzeria in the world by the 50 Top Pizza Awards in 2024 and awarded Michelin Bib Gourmand. Una Pizza Napoletana has become a global destination for pizza lovers. Yet despite the accolades, it remains deeply personal. Reservations are limited, the vibe is understated, and the focus is always on quality over quantity. For anyone serious about pizza, this isn’t just a meal—it’s a pilgrimage.

Ribalta

Just off Union Square, Ribalta feels like a slice of Naples in the middle of Manhattan. Known for its laid-back energy and unwavering commitment to tradition. Ribalta has built its reputation on Neapolitan pizza done the right way. Slow-fermented dough, San Marzano tomatoes, and a 90-second bake in a blistering hot wood-fired oven. Whether you’re a homesick Italian or just a pizza lover with standards, Ribalta hits the mark.

Highlights:

• Associazione Verace Pizza Napoletana certified (that’s official Neapolitan status)
  
• Pizza dough made with imported Italian flour and fermented for 72 hours
  
• A well-rounded menu of antipasti, pastas, and classic desserts
  

Ribalta currently holds a Google Reviews rating of 4.4 stars from over 2,500 diners, with frequent mentions of the pizza’s perfect chew and the restaurant’s convivial, no-fuss vibe. On TripAdvisor, it scores 4.5, with both tourists and locals praising the staff’s warmth and the sense of dining somewhere that feels genuinely Italian.

Its social media presence is equally inviting. On Instagram, @ribalta.restaurant has around 30K followers. Sharing behind-the-scenes clips of dough-making, shots of bubbling Margheritas, and snapshots of a dining room always full of life. It’s not trying to be trendy—it’s just effortlessly, authentically good.

Awarded #19 pizzeria in the world by the 50 Top Pizza Awards in 2024.

Ribalta is one of those places where the ingredients do the talking, the service feels like family, and the pizza lands somewhere between comfort and art. Whether you’re popping in after work or planning a proper Friday night out, Ribalta promises a pizza experience rooted in tradition—and always served with soul.

Don Antonio

Steps from the Broadway lights, Don Antonio is the kind of place that manages to feel both globally acclaimed and deeply neighbourly. Co-founded by world-renowned pizzaioli Roberto Caporuscio and Antonio Starita—whose Naples location famously served pizza to the Pope—Don Antonio brings the heart of Naples to Midtown Manhattan with a menu that celebrates tradition, innovation, and downright deliciousness.

Highlights:

• The famous Montanara Starita, a lightly fried, wood-fired pizza that’s crisp, airy, and unforgettable
  
• Extensive selection of gluten-free and vegetarian-friendly options
  
• Handmade mozzarella, imported Italian ingredients, and that signature charred crust
  

Don Antonio holds a high Google Reviews rating of 4.6 stars from over 1,600 reviews. With regulars praising the perfectly blistered dough and lightning-fast service—ideal for a pre-theatre bite or a casual night out. On TripAdvisor, the restaurant enjoys a 4.3-star average with over 2,300 reviews. It is often ranked among the best pizza experiences in New York for its balance of quality and atmosphere.

On Instagram, @donantonionewyork has around 10.4K followers. Posting everything from close-ups of molten-cheese pies to behind-the-scenes clips of dough being tossed and stretched with Neapolitan flair. It’s a feed that feels like an open invitation—one slice at a time.

Ranked #30 pizzeria in the world by the 50 Top Pizza Awards in 2024.

Don Antonio isn’t flashy. It doesn’t need to be. The food speaks louder than any signage, and the warm, bustling energy inside always feels a little like coming home. If you’re looking for serious pizza credentials without the pretence, this is where to go—and why so many return.

L’Industrie Pizzeria

In a charming corner of Brooklyn, L’Industrie Pizzeria is the kind of spot that seems to have found the perfect balance between artisan craftsmanship and the effortless cool of its neighbourhood. A love letter to the craft of pizza-making, L’Industrie brings together traditional techniques and bold innovation in a way that’s become synonymous with the Brooklyn food scene. With a menu that features both timeless favourites and daring new creations. It’s clear that this pizzeria isn’t afraid to take risks.

Highlights:

• The signature ‘Industry Pie,’ a wood-fired masterpiece topped with fresh mozzarella, spicy soppressata, and a delicate drizzle of honey—sweet, spicy, and simply unforgettable.
  
• An expansive selection of pizzas, from classic Margherita to inventive seasonal specials, all cooked to perfection with a perfectly charred crust.
  
• A commitment to locally sourced ingredients and a handcrafted approach that elevates every slice.
  

L’Industrie Pizzeria boasts a superb Google Reviews rating of 4.7 stars from over 4,200 reviews. With patrons consistently praising the artistry behind the pies and the laid-back yet energetic atmosphere that keeps the place buzzing. Over on TripAdvisor, it holds a 4.0-star rating and regularly earns a spot among the best pizza spots in New York for its unpretentious excellence.

On Instagram, @lindustriebk has cultivated a loyal following of 147K pizza lovers. Offering a steady stream of drool-worthy shots—from the first bite of a perfect pizza to time-lapse videos of dough being expertly stretched and topped. It’s a feed that tempts you to drop by for a slice… or five.

There’s nothing showy about L’Industrie Pizzeria—it doesn’t have to be. Its charm lies in its straightforward approach to great pizza, served with care and a touch of Brooklyn grit. Whether you’re coming for a casual dinner or a laid-back night out, the atmosphere feels like an invitation to stay a little longer, one bite at a time. If you want pizza that’s as good as it is real, this is the place to be—and the reason people keep coming back.

Rezdôra

Nestled in the heart of Manhattan’s Flatiron District, Rezdôra is where you go to experience the soul of Emilia-Romagna. Elevated with the kind of precision that makes every dish feel like a work of art. A celebration of hand-rolled pasta, traditional recipes, and seasonal ingredients. This Michelin-starred gem redefines what it means to savour Italian cuisine in New York City.

Highlights:

• The signature Tortellini in Brodo—small, delicate pasta parcels in a rich, velvety broth that taste like comfort and sophistication all at once
  
• A seasonal menu that changes frequently, offering an ever-evolving array of handmade pastas, fresh meats, and local produce, always crafted with impeccable attention to detail
  
• An extensive wine list featuring both Italian classics and obscure finds, curated to complement the restaurant’s beautifully layered dishes
  

Rezdôra holds a Google Reviews rating of 4.2 stars from over 1,300 reviews. With diners frequently noting the exceptional quality of the food, the warmth of the service, and the intimate yet refined atmosphere. On TripAdvisor, it scores a 3.8-star average. Many calling it one of the finest Italian dining experiences in the city. One that feels both luxurious and incredibly personal.

On Instagram, @rezdoranyc has built a devoted following of 84K. Where pasta-porn shots dominate the feed—think delicate ribbons of tagliatelle and decadent plates of ragù—and a few candid glimpses of the kitchen staff rolling out dough with the kind of care that shows in every bite. It’s the kind of feed that makes you want to make a reservation… yesterday.

There’s a quiet elegance about Rezdôra. It’s not about flash; it’s about creating an experience that lingers in your memory long after the meal is over. The food speaks for itself—honest, soulful, and always perfect. If you’re looking for an exceptional taste of Emilia-Romagna without ever leaving the city, this is the place—and the reason why Rezdôra has become a staple for both locals and visitors alike.

Marea

Perched on the edge of Central Park South, Marea is the kind of restaurant that commands attention without shouting. A seafood sanctuary that feels both lavish and inviting. It delivers an experience that blends coastal Italian flavours with fine-dining finesse. With its Michelin-starred reputation, Marea continues to stand as one of the city’s most revered spots for seafood, offering a menu that’s as refined as it is innovative.

Highlights:

• The famous Fusilli with Red Lobster, a dish that redefines pasta with its rich, buttery sauce and perfectly cooked lobster—a true showstopper
  
• A seasonal selection of impeccably fresh crudo, served with delicate accompaniments that highlight the natural flavours of the fish
  
• An extensive wine list, featuring top Italian selections and rare finds. All curated to complement the delicate yet bold flavours of the menu
  

Marea boasts a Google Reviews rating of 4.5 stars from over 2,700 reviews. Diners consistently praising the exceptional quality of the seafood, the polished yet warm service, and the stunning views of Central Park. On TripAdvisor, it holds a 4.4-star average from over 2,300 reviews. Often ranked among the top fine-dining restaurants in New York for its attention to detail and timeless elegance.

On Instagram, @marearestaurants has a loyal following of 85.6K, with a feed that features everything from close-ups of pristine seafood dishes to behind-the-scenes glimpses of the kitchen’s precision. The images reflect a sense of effortless luxury, making it the kind of account you can’t help but scroll through before making a reservation.

Marea is the epitome of understated luxury. It’s not flashy, but it doesn’t need to be—its dishes speak volumes with their perfect balance of flavours and textures. Whether you’re dining in for a special occasion or indulging in an exceptional meal, Marea offers a dining experience that feels timeless, always leaving you wanting more. If you’re after a refined seafood experience that never compromises on quality, this is the place—and the reason so many return, again and again.

Kesté Pizza & Vino

Tucked away in the bustling streets of the West Village, Kesté Pizza & Vino is where pizza dreams come true. With a dedication to traditional Neapolitan methods, this beloved pizzeria transports you straight to the heart of Naples, offering an authentic taste of Italy in every bite. Warm and welcoming, Kesté is the kind of place where the quality of the food speaks for itself. Every pizza is crafted with the kind of care that only a true pizzaiolo can offer.

Highlights:

• The classic Margherita, with its perfectly blistered crust, fresh mozzarella, and bright tomato sauce—a dish that embodies the essence of simplicity and excellence
  
• A wide range of traditional and creative pizza options, all cooked in a wood-fired oven to achieve that signature charred, chewy crust
  
• An extensive selection of Italian wines, carefully chosen to complement the bold and nuanced flavours of the pizzas
  

Kesté boasts a Google Reviews rating of 4.6 stars from over 2,900 reviews, with guests praising the authenticity of the pizzas, the friendly service, and the relaxed atmosphere that feels like a little slice of Italy in New York. On TripAdvisor, it holds a 4.5-star average from over 1,200 reviews. Ranking as one of the best pizzerias in the city for its commitment to tradition and quality.

On Instagram, @kestepizza has built a strong following of 28.8K pizza lovers. Showcasing everything from close-ups of perfectly melted mozzarella to videos of pizzas emerging from the wood-fired oven with that signature sizzle. The feed is a celebration of all things pizza, and it’s the kind of account that makes your stomach growl and your mouth water. There’s a humility to Kesté, a sense that it doesn’t need to boast or make a spectacle of itself. Its pizzas do all the talking, with a level of care and craftsmanship that brings diners back time and time again. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or settling in for a leisurely meal, Kesté always delivers—offering a slice of Naples in every bite. If you’re after authentic, soul-satisfying pizza in New York, this is the place—and the reason so many swear by it.

Via Carota

Via Carota, also in the West Village, is a rustic yet refined slice of Italy. Where simplicity meets sophistication in every dish. Known for its comforting Italian fare and a menu that’s as timeless as the neighbourhood itself. Via Carota offers a dining experience that feels both intimate and effortlessly chic. With a focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients and traditional techniques, it’s no wonder this cosy trattoria has become a beloved favourite in New York’s ever-evolving food scene.

Highlights:

• The iconic Frittura di Verdure, a golden, crispy assortment of seasonal vegetables, showcasing the restaurant’s commitment to fresh, vibrant flavours
  
• A menu that rotates with the seasons. Offering everything from rich pastas like the Pappardelle al Ragù to tender meat and fish dishes that capture the essence of Italian cooking
  
• A carefully curated list of Italian wines and cocktails, chosen to complement the menu’s focus on simplicity and bold, natural flavours
  

Via Carota holds a Google Reviews rating of 4.4 stars from over 2,800 reviews. Guests consistently raving about the quality of the food, the impeccable service, and the inviting atmosphere that makes you feel like you’ve stumbled into an Italian villa. On TripAdvisor, it scores a 4.3-star average, earning accolades as one of the most authentic Italian dining experiences in New York City.

On Instagram, @viacarota has gathered a loyal following of 121K. With a feed full of mouthwatering shots—from delicate plates of pasta to vibrant vegetable dishes—and an occasional glimpse behind the scenes, showing the kitchen staff at work with the kind of passion that elevates every dish. It’s the type of account that makes you want to drop everything and make a reservation.

There’s a quiet elegance to Via Carota. It doesn’t try to impress; it simply delivers. The atmosphere feels like you’re dining in someone’s home, and the food is unpretentious yet extraordinary. Whether you’re there for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, Via Carota is a place that feels like a warm embrace—one that lingers long after you’ve left. If you’re searching for authentic Italian food in a cosy, stylish setting, this is the place—and the reason people keep returning, time after time.

Lilia

Lilia brings the flavours of Italy to Brooklyn, offering wood-fired seafood and handcrafted pastas. Chef Missy Robbins’ culinary expertise shines through in each dish, making it a must-visit for Italian cuisine enthusiasts. The space itself is warm and industrial-chic, with an open kitchen that adds a layer of intimacy to the dining experience.

Highlights:

• Innovative takes on classic Italian dishes
  
• Standouts include the sheep’s milk agnolotti and rigatoni diavola
  
• Wood-fired prawns and delicate gelati among fan favourites
  

Lilia currently holds a Google Reviews rating of 4.3, based on over 2,000 reviews. With diners consistently praising the balance of simplicity and refinement. On TripAdvisor, the restaurant also maintains a 4.3-star average, reflecting its popularity among both locals and international visitors.

Over on Instagram, @lilianewyork has amassed more than 157K followers. Sharing behind-the-scenes shots, beautifully plated dishes, and seasonal menu updates—giving fans a taste of the Lilia experience even before they book.

Carbone

Celebrity favourite Carbone is where old-school glamour meets sharp culinary execution. From its tuxedoed waiters to the retro-tiled floors and Sinatra-infused soundtrack. This Greenwich Village icon is as much about experience as it is about food. Despite its celebrity clientele and paparazzi buzz, Carbone delivers where it matters most: on the plate.

Highlights:

• Signature dishes include spicy rigatoni vodka, veal parmesan, and Caesar salad prepared tableside
  
• A curated Italian wine list and vintage cocktail programme
  
• Classic New York meets Little Italy ambience, perfect for date nights or special occasions
  

On Google Reviews, the Michele Guide Carbone holds a rating of 4.3 stars from over 2,200 reviews. With praise focusing on the consistently polished service and the balance of nostalgia with genuine culinary talent. On TripAdvisor, it averages a solid 4.0, where visitors rave about the lively atmosphere and bold, satisfying flavours.

Socially, Carbone is something of an institution. On Instagram, @majorfoodgroup has racked up a whopping 286K followers. Postings range from crave-worthy close-ups of the spicy rigatoni to throwback branding and behind-the-scenes moments. The account encapsulates the brand’s effortless cool—equal parts charm, confidence, and culinary swagger.